NEW DELHI: Drawing a distinction between professional journalists and social media content creators, Delhi Police has told the Supreme Court that people making reels cannot automatically claim the special protection and privileges available to media professionals.
In affidavits filed by Delhi Police Commissioner Anurag Kumar and Joint Commissioner of Police Surinder Kumar, the force defended its action during last month’s protests at Jantar Mantar against Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar.
The affidavits were submitted in response to petitions by several journalist organisations, including the Network of Women in Media, Free Speech Collective and the Delhi Union of Journalists. The petitions alleged police excesses against journalists covering the protests.
Delhi Police told the court that some people participating in what it described as “illegal protests” were carrying cameras and microphones and making YouTube reels. This, it said, made it difficult for police personnel at the spot to distinguish professional journalists from those creating social media content.
The police officers clarified that they had no intention of obstructing the work of content creators. However, they said the guidelines governing media coverage of protests were designed to distinguish professional journalists from individuals using cameras for commercial gains.
Reiterating its respect for the role of the press, Delhi Police said journalists belonged to a distinct category and that people making reels on social media for commercial purposes did not automatically qualify for press-related facilities or protection.
The affidavits stated that in the digital media era, many people create reels for commercial benefits, which is not objectionable in itself. However, whether such content creators can be accorded the status of journalists or reporters remains a matter to be determined.
According to the police, the distinction between a journalist and a content creator can be assessed by examining the primary purpose behind a person’s activities.
Further clarifying its position, Delhi Police said it had never interfered with the work of those honestly performing their journalistic duties.
Citing previous Supreme Court orders, the police said judicial protection was meant for journalists carrying out their professional responsibilities and was not intended to exempt social media influencers or troublemakers violating the law at prohibited gatherings from its application.



